Liverpool v Man United: why three points matter more than another rout
There is a particular kind of greed that creeps in whenever Manchester United come to Anfield. After the last few years, plenty of us walk into the ground half expecting a hammering. Jamie Carragher thinks that mindset is a trap, and our take is that he has a point.
This weekend’s meeting has an unusual edge to it. Andoni Iraola takes charge of Liverpool against United for the first time, while Mauricio Pochettino is thrown straight in at the deep end after taking over from Michael Carrick at Old Trafford. Two new men in the dugout, two very different sets of problems.

United in a hole
The visitors are in a really bad place. Eight points from their first ten Premier League games leaves them in the relegation zone, and Pochettino has had barely any time with his squad after the November international break.
Read more: Alisson or Mamardashvili? Liverpool’s goalkeeping standoff needs settling
Speaking on The Overlap Daily, Carragher said he does not expect a sudden transformation. His argument was simple: a new manager with a day or two on the training ground can change a formation or move a few players around, but he cannot fix confidence and habits that have built up over years. Many of the players at United, Carragher noted, have already been there through several managers, and the problems have followed them.
We would agree. Tactical tweaks can arrive overnight. Real organisation, belief and understanding between players take weeks, often months.
Liverpool are not flying either
Carragher was honest about Liverpool too. He admitted they are not playing brilliantly right now, pointing out that while they were impressive at home against Arsenal last time out, they did not register a single shot on target. His view is that if Liverpool bring the pace, energy and noise of Anfield into the game, they should have enough.
That is the challenge for Iraola. His side has shown flashes of what he wants, especially in the intensity of their pressing and their ability to pin teams back, but those promising spells still need turning into convincing wins. He inherited a team that slid badly in Arne Slot’s second season after the title win of 2024/25, and steadiness is what this group needs most. Against United, managing transitions and keeping the defensive shape tight could make the difference.
Stop dreaming of seven
The part of Carragher’s comments that really landed with us was about expectations. Liverpool fans have been spoiled in this fixture, with the 7-0 at Anfield in March 2023 the obvious high point, alongside a 5-0 and a 4-0 that live long in the memory. Carragher admitted those results make him nervous as a supporter, because they create a feeling that anything less than a rout is a let down.
His message boiled down to two words: “Just win”. He argued that those huge scorelines are one offs, the kind of games we will still be talking about in 30 years precisely because they are not normal. He also pointed out that United have a respectable record at Anfield in recent seasons, which is worth remembering before anyone starts predicting the score.
Our take
We think this is exactly the right attitude. A scrappy 1-0 against a struggling rival would be worth every bit as much in the table as another thrashing, and it would hand Iraola an early statement win in the fixture that matters most to this fanbase.
Pochettino is no novice in big Premier League games either, so assuming there will be no new manager bounce at all would be a mistake. Liverpool should respect that and focus on themselves. Three points, a controlled performance, and nobody should care about the margin.
More: Liverpool FC News →