LatestGustavo Varela’s Goal Rush Has Liverpool Watching, But Do We Actually Need Him?

Craig’s Column: Howard Webb Must Stop Making Excuses, Premier League Fans Deserve Better

November 21, 2026 · Craig Houlden · Posted 6 hours ago

Liverpool Have Been Let Down By VAR, And I’m Tired of Hearing Excuses

I’m absolutely fed up with listening to Howard Webb explain why Premier League referees keep getting decisions wrong.

Every season, we hear the same things. Mistakes have been made. Lessons will be learned. Standards must improve.

And then we turn up the following weekend, pay our money, watch another controversial decision and find ourselves having exactly the same conversation.

Read more: Craig’s Column: Liverpool Are Right To Let Joe Gomez Go, But He Deserves A Proper Goodbye

How many times are football supporters supposed to accept this?

I’ve been angry about refereeing decisions before. Anyone who watches Anfield Agenda knows that. But what really gets under my skin is the complete lack of meaningful accountability.

We’re constantly told how difficult the job is. We’re reminded that referees are human beings and that mistakes happen.

I understand all of that.

What I don’t understand is why an organisation with access to multiple camera angles, video assistants and sophisticated technology still seems incapable of consistently applying the laws of football.

And when mistakes happen, why are supporters expected to accept another explanation and move on?

I’m sorry, but that isn’t good enough anymore.

Howard Webb’s Latest Admission Raises More Questions

According to reporting from Martin Ziegler of The Times, Webb has acknowledged to Premier League clubs that officials need to improve following a series of mistakes.

The report suggested there had been six incidents across the opening 100 matches where VAR should have intervened but failed to do so.

Six.

And apparently, we’re also supposed to celebrate the fact that VAR delays have been reduced because officials are being encouraged to respect the referee’s original decision unless there’s a clear and obvious error.

There it is again.

Clear and obvious error.

Those four words have become the perfect escape route for the people running our refereeing system.

What exactly qualifies as clear and obvious?

Who decides when the threshold has been reached? How are we supposed to measure it? And why do incidents that look remarkably similar sometimes produce completely different outcomes?

If Webb wants supporters to trust the system, he needs to provide answers that make sense.

Because telling us that VAR should have intervened in six incidents while simultaneously emphasising that video officials shouldn’t undermine referees leaves me wondering what the priorities actually are.

Are we trying to make the correct decisions, or are we trying to protect the authority of the person holding the whistle?

For me, getting the decision right should always come first.

Liverpool Have Every Reason To Be Frustrated

I know people will immediately accuse me of looking at this through Liverpool-tinted glasses.

Fine. I’m a Liverpool supporter. I’m not pretending otherwise.

But my frustration extends well beyond one football club.

Look at some of the decisions we’ve experienced.

Alexander Isak having his shirt pulled when he’s in a position to attack the ball. The controversial penalty involving Milos Kerkez. Ryan Gravenberch’s dismissal against Manchester City.

We can debate individual incidents all day, and supporters of other clubs will have their own examples.

What concerns me is the inconsistency.

In the Isak incident, the Key Match Incidents Panel reportedly concluded by a four-to-one majority that a penalty should have been awarded. A narrower three-to-two majority felt VAR should have recommended an on-field review.

That’s an extraordinary illustration of the problem.

Even the people reviewing these incidents can agree that the original decision was wrong while disagreeing about whether VAR should have corrected it.

How is that a satisfactory system?

We’ve seen similar frustration with previous Liverpool incidents, including Luis Díaz’s wrongly disallowed goal against Tottenham and the handball controversy involving Martin Ødegaard.

These moments stay with supporters because the consequences matter.

Points matter. League positions matter. European qualification matters. Trophies matter.

You cannot simply hand a football club an apology and pretend the sporting consequences disappear.

And while I’m not claiming that every poor decision is evidence of corruption or deliberate bias, I absolutely reject the suggestion that supporters should stop asking difficult questions.

Questioning the quality of officiating is entirely legitimate.

Craig’s Column: Howard Webb Must Stop Making Excuses, Premier League Fans Deserve Better

VAR Needs Transparency, Not Another Television Explanation

Here’s something I genuinely want to know.

Are referees becoming reluctant to make big decisions because they believe VAR will rescue them?

Think about it.

A referee sees something in the penalty area. He’s uncertain. Rather than make the decision, perhaps he allows play to continue because he knows there’s somebody watching the footage.

But then the VAR official is told to avoid intervening unless the error is clear and obvious.

Can you see the problem?

We potentially have one official reluctant to make the initial decision and another reluctant to overturn it.

That is a system which risks encouraging hesitation.

I want referees to make decisions confidently, and I want VAR to correct mistakes when the evidence supports doing so.

I also want to hear the conversations.

Rugby has demonstrated how much transparency can help supporters understand the reasoning behind important decisions.

Why can’t football move further in that direction?

Why should we have to wait for a television programme where selected incidents are discussed after the event?

Let us hear what officials are saying in real time. Let us understand how they arrive at their conclusions.

If a decision is difficult, explain why.

If somebody gets it wrong, acknowledge the mistake and demonstrate what will change.

And if officials repeatedly fail to meet the required standard, there must be consequences.

That’s how accountability works in virtually every other profession.

I don’t see why Premier League refereeing should be treated differently.

Premier League Risks Losing Supporters’ Trust

Something else has been bothering me recently.

I genuinely feel there’s a growing sense of disillusionment around English football.

We’ve got the prolonged uncertainty surrounding Manchester City’s financial charges and the related legal processes. We’ve got ongoing arguments about governance. We’ve got supporters increasingly questioning the consistency of refereeing decisions.

None of that helps people feel confident about the competition they’re watching.

And then you add the financial demands placed on supporters.

Match tickets, travel, television subscriptions and everything else associated with following a football club.

People invest enormous amounts of time, money and emotion into this sport.

They deserve a competition administered to the highest possible standard.

I’m not expecting perfection. Nobody sensible expects every referee to get every decision right.

But I do expect improvement.

And I expect the people responsible for delivering that improvement to be judged on results rather than the quality of their explanations.

If Webb believes the system is working, show us the evidence.

Publish meaningful assessments. Explain the thresholds. Make the decision-making process more transparent.

Stop asking supporters to accept vague reassurances.

We’ve got Manchester United coming to Anfield on Sunday, and I should be spending every minute thinking about the football.

I should be thinking about how Andoni Iraola approaches the match, whether Liverpool can take advantage of United’s weaknesses and how important three points would be.

Instead, part of me is already wondering whether we’ll end up talking about another refereeing controversy.

That’s a terrible reflection on where we are.

I want Liverpool to win because they’re the better team on the day. If we lose, I want to be able to acknowledge that the opposition deserved it.

I don’t want another weekend dominated by arguments about whether VAR should have intervened.

Howard Webb has a responsibility to restore confidence in the system.

And if he cannot demonstrate genuine, sustained improvement, I think it’s reasonable to question whether he’s the right person to lead it.

Because football supporters have heard enough apologies.

We want accountability. We want consistency. And above everything else, we want to trust the game we’re watching.

Much Love.

More: Craig’s Column: Daily Liverpool Opinion →

Live