Liverpool Risk Losing Mac Allister While Making Excuses Over Camara
I’m getting a little bit fed up with Liverpool finding reasons not to do what we all know needs doing.
We’ve got a midfield problem. We’ve had a midfield problem for some time. And now, with the January transfer window approaching, we’re hearing suggestions that Liverpool might struggle to bring in Lamine Camara because we’d have too many midfielders.
Too many midfielders?
Read more: Craig’s Column: Bradley Barcola Is Being Judged Far Too Quickly At Liverpool
Have I missed something?
Because when I look at this Liverpool squad, I see a team that has been crying out for a proper number six. I see a manager trying to implement a demanding system without all the players he needs. And I see a club that has spent far too many years leaving itself short in important positions.
David Lynch was speaking to Anfield Index about the possibility of Camara arriving in January, and his view was that a significant departure might be needed to make room.
I respect David, but I couldn’t disagree more strongly with that argument.
If Liverpool have the opportunity to sign a player who improves our midfield in January, we should get the deal done.
We can worry about who stays and who goes afterwards.
Liverpool Cannot Keep Making Excuses About Squad Depth
I keep coming back to this idea that Liverpool don’t like being overstocked.
Well, when exactly have we been overstocked?
Because I can’t remember too many Liverpool supporters complaining that we’ve had an embarrassment of riches across the squad.
Quite the opposite.
We’ve gone into seasons worrying about defensive cover, midfield options and whether we’ve got enough quality to compete across four competitions.
Now we’re being told that adding a player who could solve an obvious tactical problem might leave us with too many bodies.
I don’t buy it.
Curtis Jones has gone. Wataru Endo isn’t featuring regularly and looks likely to move on. Trey Nyoni has stepped up, and I’m delighted about that, but surely we should be giving the lad proper competition rather than expecting him to carry the responsibility himself.
Look at the midfielders we’re discussing.
We’ve got Alexis Mac Allister, Dominik Szoboszlai, Ryan Gravenberch and Nyoni competing for the two deeper positions in Iraola’s system.
That’s hardly an outrageous amount of depth.
And remember, we’re asking these lads to play an intense brand of football while competing in the Premier League, Champions League and domestic cups.
If we sign Camara in January and end up with one or two players disappointed about their minutes, so be it.
Welcome to playing for Liverpool Football Club.

Lamine Camara Gives Iraola Something Liverpool Are Missing
What I like about Camara is that he looks suited to what we’re trying to build.
He’s energetic, press-resistant and capable of operating as either a number six or a number eight.
He’s somebody who can get around the pitch, compete physically and help give our midfield the balance it’s been missing.
And that’s the important part.
We’ve got good footballers at Liverpool. I’m not questioning that.
What I’m questioning is whether we’ve got the right footballers for the way Iraola wants his team to play.
There’s a difference.
I don’t want to spend another six months watching opponents run through the middle of our team because we haven’t got the balance right.
I don’t want to watch us surrender control of matches because our midfielders are being asked to do jobs that don’t suit them.
And I certainly don’t want to hear that we couldn’t strengthen because we were worried about upsetting somebody already at the club.
Camara has been linked with Liverpool, and there have been conversations involving his representatives, according to the information I’ve discussed.
That doesn’t mean a January transfer is guaranteed. Monaco still have their own interests, and there’s a deal to be negotiated.
But if he’s attainable, I want Liverpool to make a serious attempt to get him.
If he improves our chances of qualifying for the Champions League and winning a trophy, why would we wait?
Ryan Gravenberch Has A Serious Question To Answer
Now, this is where people might get annoyed with me.
Because if Liverpool eventually decide that somebody needs to leave midfield, I think Ryan Gravenberch has to be part of that conversation.
I’m not saying he’s a bad footballer.
I’m not forgetting what he contributed when Liverpool won the Premier League in 2024/25.
He deserves credit for that season, and nobody can take it away from him.
But we’re in 2026/27 now.
At what point do we stop talking about what somebody did eighteen months ago and start judging what they’re doing today?
Gravenberch hasn’t consistently reached those standards since.
I don’t think he’s a natural number six in the system we’re playing. I don’t think he’s a number ten. And if we’re talking about him as a number eight, I would have Mac Allister and Szoboszlai ahead of him.
That’s a problem.
Especially when we’re talking about a player on an enormous contract.
I’m not criticising Ryan for negotiating good wages. Fair play to him.
But Liverpool have to ask whether they’re getting the performances those wages should command.
And I don’t think they are.
Some supporters will tell me that he’s got a higher ceiling than Mac Allister.
Maybe he has. Maybe he doesn’t.
But football isn’t played on hypothetical ceilings.
It’s played on the pitch, every weekend.
And right now, Mac Allister is giving us more.
Could Gravenberch rediscover his best form over the next six months? Absolutely.
I’d love him to prove me wrong.
But let’s bring Camara in and give him that challenge.
If Ryan responds brilliantly, fantastic. If he doesn’t, Liverpool will have a decision to make in the summer.
That’s how a competitive football club should operate.

Alexis Mac Allister Must Not Become Another Liverpool Contract Mistake
My biggest concern in all of this is that Liverpool somehow end up losing the wrong midfielder.
Alexis Mac Allister is playing excellent football, he’s a World Cup winner, he’s experienced and he’s exactly the sort of player I want in this team.
Yet we’re allowing his contract to run down to a point where the club could find itself in a very uncomfortable position.
We’ve been here before.
Liverpool spend years telling us how important financial discipline is, then allow valuable players to approach the end of their contracts and weaken their own negotiating position.
How does that make sense?
Arsenal are reportedly moving to secure Declan Rice on a new long-term deal.
They’re protecting one of their most important players.
Liverpool should be doing exactly the same with Mac Allister.
If you asked me which midfield I’d rather take into next season, one containing Camara, Nyoni, Szoboszlai and Gravenberch, or one containing Camara, Nyoni, Szoboszlai and Mac Allister, it’s not even a difficult decision.
I’m keeping Mac Allister.
Every single time.
And I don’t want us to get to the summer and discover that we’ve lost him for a fraction of his value while we’re still discussing whether Gravenberch might eventually fulfil his potential.
That would be another failure of planning.
So here’s what I’d do.
Get serious about Camara in January. Get Mac Allister’s contract sorted. Give Gravenberch and Szoboszlai the opportunity to prove they belong in Iraola’s long-term plans.
Then make the difficult decisions in the summer.
We don’t need to sell somebody tomorrow to justify signing the player we need today.
We need competition. We need balance. And we need a football club prepared to act like it wants to win things.
Because I’m tired of hearing why Liverpool can’t do something.
I’d much rather see us actually do it.
Much Love.