LatestKoni De Winter feels like the sensible centre-back answer Liverpool need

Two more years for Van Dijk is the easiest call Liverpool will make all season

November 17, 2026 · Emma Richardson · Posted 7 hours ago

Why Iraola should want his captain tied down well beyond this campaign

Every club eventually reaches the awkward moment where loyalty to a great player collides with cold squad planning. With Virgil van Dijk, we would argue Liverpool have not reached that moment yet, and the evidence on the pitch says they are nowhere close to it.

The debate over our captain’s contract has picked up again, and one of the more measured voices covering the club has come down firmly on the side of keeping him. Journalist David Lynch, speaking on a Liverpool podcast with Dave Davis, described an extension as a no-brainer, and the longer you look at it, the harder it becomes to disagree.

Two more years for Van Dijk is the easiest call Liverpool will make all season
Photo: IMAGO | Anfield Index

The decline argument does not stand up

Nobody is pretending Van Dijk is the same unplayable monster who arrived from Southampton and changed the entire shape of the club. Lynch accepted that point himself. He was happy to concede that the Dutchman may have dropped a fraction from his very best years, but he also made the obvious counterpoint: try naming a centre-half in the Premier League who is clearly better right now.

Read more: Craig’s Column: Liverpool Must Sign Lamine Camara, Even If Gravenberch Has To Go

Lynch also raised an interesting wrinkle when the conversation turned to Arsenal’s pairing of Gabriel and William Saliba. His view was that those two operate in a structure built to shelter them, while Liverpool’s defender is often left exposed by the way the team is set up. Put Van Dijk in that kind of protective system, he suggested, and he would cruise. We think that is a fair reading. Defenders are judged on what they are asked to do, and ours is asked to do a lot.

What he still brings to an Iraola side

Under Andoni Iraola, Liverpool press high and invite a steady stream of long balls over the top. That approach lives or dies on having someone at the back who wins the first header and does not panic when the ball drops behind him. Lynch pointed to exactly that, highlighting how commanding Van Dijk remains in the air and why that matters so much for a pressing side.

He also noted that the captain still looks comfortable in possession, does not appear to have lost his pace in any meaningful way, and remains as physically strong as ever. For a player in the latter stages of his career, that is a remarkable list. Most centre-backs at this point are being hidden. Van Dijk is still the one doing the hiding for others.

Availability and leadership seal it

For us, the most persuasive part of the case is the least glamorous. Van Dijk is almost always fit. Lynch made a point of praising how rarely he misses matches, and in a squad that has spent long stretches juggling injuries, that reliability is worth an enormous amount.

Then there is the dressing room. Lynch spoke about Van Dijk being an outstanding captain who clearly enjoys being around the club. That counts for more during a transition like this one, with a relatively new head coach still putting his stamp on the group. Ripping out the most authoritative voice in the building would be a strange way to support Iraola.

The proposed solution is sensible too. Lynch’s preference is a two-year deal, reasoning that centre-backs who do not need to cover huge distances can extend their careers more comfortably than players in other positions. Two years protects Liverpool from being stuck with a long tail on the contract while keeping a leader in place through a crucial period.

The bigger defensive picture

Lynch did acknowledge that the decision feeds into wider planning. What Liverpool do with Van Dijk will shape how they approach the rest of the defence, from any interest in Ronald Araujo to decisions at right-back and the return of younger options from loan or injury. Settle the captain’s future first, and every other call becomes easier to plan around.

Our take is simple. Van Dijk is still elite, still available and still the leader this squad needs. Two more years is not sentiment. It is good business.

More: Liverpool Opinion & Analysis →

Live