LatestWataru Endo deserves a proper Anfield farewell as his Liverpool days wind down

Craig’s Column: Why I Agree With Carragher About Liverpool’s January Transfer Plans

November 18, 2026 · Craig Houlden · Posted 5 hours ago

Jamie Carragher Is Right, Liverpool Cannot Waste Another January Window

I never thought I’d be sitting here agreeing with Jamie Carragher quite so enthusiastically, but here we are.

I’ve had plenty to say about Carra recently. I haven’t liked some of his criticism of Florian Wirtz, and I certainly haven’t liked the way he’s spoken about sections of the Liverpool fanbase.

But when somebody gets something right, I’ll give them credit.

Read more: Craig’s Column: Liverpool Must Sign Lamine Camara, Even If Gravenberch Has To Go

And on Liverpool’s January transfer plans, I think Carragher is absolutely spot on.

He wants Liverpool to strengthen in January rather than wait until the summer. He has identified the full-back positions and midfield as areas that need attention, and he’s made an important point about Andoni Iraola’s contract.

We’ve only got two years guaranteed with this manager.

That means every transfer window matters.

And if Liverpool are serious about challenging for the Premier League title next season, they cannot afford to spend another January telling us that everything is fine.

Because everything isn’t fine.

Liverpool’s Midfield Problem Is Staring Everyone In The Face

James Pearce has reported that Liverpool don’t believe there’s a glaring hole in the squad, although they would consider bringing forward a summer transfer if the right opportunity appeared.

I’m sorry, but what?

How can anybody look at Liverpool’s midfield this season and conclude that there’s no obvious problem?

We’ve been talking about the need for a proper number six for months. We’ve watched Iraola try to find the right balance. We’ve seen the issues that arise when players are asked to operate in roles that don’t naturally suit them.

And we’re still having the same conversation.

I like James Pearce as a person. I’ve said that repeatedly, and I mean it.

But I find some of the reporting around Liverpool’s transfer strategy increasingly frustrating.

When the club’s position is that there’s no glaring deficiency, I want somebody to challenge that. I want somebody to ask how that conclusion has been reached when supporters can see the problems every week.

Maybe Liverpool are deliberately keeping their cards close to their chest. Maybe they’re trying to manage expectations.

Fair enough.

But supporters shouldn’t be expected to accept the idea that this squad is perfectly balanced.

Lamine Camara remains a player of interest, according to the reporting discussed this week.

For me, if Liverpool believe he’s the right midfielder for Iraola and there’s a realistic opportunity to sign him in January, they should make it happen.

Why wait until the summer?

A player arriving now gets several months to understand the manager, build relationships and settle into the Premier League.

That’s valuable preparation for next season, before we even consider what he could contribute to this one.

Craig’s Column: Why I Agree With Carragher About Liverpool’s January Transfer Plans
Photo: IMAGO / Anfield Index

Milos Kerkez And Jeremie Frimpong Raise Difficult Questions

The full-back situation is every bit as concerning.

Let’s start with Milos Kerkez.

I wanted Liverpool to sign him. I thought he was an exciting player, and I could see why the club believed he’d be a good fit.

He’s energetic, aggressive and clearly willing to work.

But we’re now at the point where I have to ask whether he’s actually delivering what Liverpool need.

His final ball isn’t good enough consistently. His decision-making needs improvement, and I’d like to see more intelligent overlapping runs to create space for Bradley Barcola.

Sometimes everything feels like it’s happening at a hundred miles an hour.

And when you’re playing at that speed, you’ve still got to make the right decisions.

That’s where Kerkez is struggling.

I’m not saying sell him tomorrow. I’m not giving up on the lad.

But I do think Liverpool need genuine competition at left-back, and if a suitable player becomes available in January, I’d seriously consider making that move.

Lewis Hall would be very high on my wish list, although Newcastle reportedly have no intention of entertaining January offers.

Then there’s Jeremie Frimpong.

And this is the difficult one because he seems like a lovely lad.

But I never really understood the signing, and I haven’t seen anything to convince me that he’s going to become an important player under Iraola.

The injuries haven’t helped. It’s incredibly difficult to build momentum when you’re constantly trying to get fit again.

But even putting that aside, where does he fit?

Ronald Araújo has been doing well at right-back. Conor Bradley still has the potential to make that position his own if he can overcome his injury problems.

And I don’t see Frimpong as a natural solution further forward.

If a reasonable offer arrived in January, I’d listen to it.

That’s not personal. That’s football.

Craig’s Column: Why I Agree With Carragher About Liverpool’s January Transfer Plans
Photo: IMAGO / Anfield Index

Iraola Needs Players Who Fit His System

One thing Liverpool have to establish is exactly what they want from their full-backs.

Are we looking for traditional attacking players who overlap and deliver crosses?

Are we looking for defenders who can tuck inside and effectively create a back three?

Or are we moving towards something closer to the approach we’ve seen from Arsenal, with centre-backs occupying positions that would once have belonged to conventional full-backs?

The links with Joško Gvardiol are interesting in that respect.

Anfield Watch have suggested Liverpool could rival Barcelona for the Manchester City defender.

I have no independent information to confirm how serious that interest is, and I’m certainly not pretending a transfer is close.

But I like Gvardiol as a footballer.

I wanted Liverpool to sign him before he went to City, and his ability to operate at centre-back or left-back would give Iraola options.

There’s also the question of Araújo’s long-term role.

Reports from Spain suggest Liverpool would like to negotiate a lower fee than the €55 million purchase option agreed with Barcelona.

I’d love that to happen.

He’s settled well, he looks happy, and he’s shown his quality.

But Liverpool need to decide whether they see him primarily as a right-back or a centre-back. That decision affects everything else we do in the market.

We can’t keep buying players without having a clear picture of where they’re supposed to fit.

Craig’s Column: Why I Agree With Carragher About Liverpool’s January Transfer Plans
Photo: IMAGO / Anfield Index

January Could Define Liverpool’s Next Title Challenge

Here’s the part of Carragher’s argument that I think deserves the most attention.

This season isn’t solely about where Liverpool finish in May.

It’s also about making sure Iraola has a team capable of challenging from the first weekend of next season.

And the sooner we give him the right players, the better.

Imagine signing a midfielder and a full-back in January.

They’d have the remainder of this campaign to settle, learn the system and establish themselves.

We’d go into pre-season knowing far more about the squad rather than scrambling around trying to complete important business in August.

And who knows what those additions could do immediately?

Liverpool are still fighting for important objectives this season.

We’re not writing it off.

We’ve got Manchester United coming to Anfield on Sunday, and I’m confident we can beat them. But one good result doesn’t suddenly eliminate the weaknesses we’ve been discussing.

That’s why I want Liverpool to be proactive.

I don’t want another transfer window dominated by explanations about why the timing wasn’t right.

I don’t want to hear that a position wasn’t a priority when we’ve spent months watching the same problems.

And I certainly don’t want us to reach next summer needing to make three or four decisions that could have been made in January.

Carragher is right.

Every window matters, particularly when you’ve appointed a manager on a two-year deal and expect him to build a title-winning side.

Give Iraola the tools.

Give him the players who suit his football.

And stop pretending there aren’t obvious areas that need strengthening.

Because Liverpool have an opportunity to get ahead of the curve here.

I’d hate to see us waste it.

Much Love.

More: Craig’s Column: Daily Liverpool Opinion →