LatestRonald Araujo has turned a loan gamble into Liverpool’s easiest summer call

Craig’s Column: Liverpool Must Sign Alex Scott Or Lamine Camara, And Keep Alexis Mac Allister

November 19, 2026 · Craig Houlden · Posted 2 hours ago

Liverpool’s £80m Alex Scott Dilemma Could Define Their January Window

I’m getting increasingly frustrated with the conversation around Liverpool’s midfield.

We’ve spent months discussing what Andoni Iraola needs. We’ve watched players struggle to adapt to his system, we’ve questioned the balance in the middle of the park, and we’ve repeatedly asked Liverpool to bring in somebody who can make a genuine difference.

Now we’re approaching January, and we’re hearing about Alex Scott and Lamine Camara.

Read more: Craig’s Column: Why I Agree With Carragher About Liverpool’s January Transfer Plans

Good.

That’s exactly the conversation I want Liverpool to be having.

But here’s where I stand on it. If Iraola wants Alex Scott, go and get Alex Scott. If he wants Lamine Camara, go and get Camara.

What I cannot accept is Liverpool deciding they don’t need either of them.

Because I think that would be a massive mistake.

Alex Scott Or Lamine Camara? Liverpool Must Back Iraola

Sky Sports have reported that Liverpool see Alex Scott as an ideal addition to their midfield, somebody who would bring guile and passing ability to the team.

And it makes sense.

Iraola knows Scott from their time together at Bournemouth. He understands what the player can offer, knows his personality and has already worked with him in a demanding Premier League environment.

There’s enormous value in that.

We’re talking about a manager who wants his players to press aggressively, move the ball quickly and understand their responsibilities without needing six months to learn everything.

Scott could potentially arrive and adapt very quickly.

But there’s a problem.

The reported asking price is somewhere between £75 million and £80 million, with additional bonuses potentially involved.

I’m sorry, but that’s an awful lot of money.

We’ve even heard suggestions of £100 million being discussed, and I don’t believe there’s any realistic chance Bournemouth receive that amount.

Scott is a very good footballer. He’s homegrown, he’s Premier League proven, and he’s somebody the manager knows.

But £100 million?

Absolutely not.

Bournemouth reportedly haven’t been able to agree a new contract with him, and that changes their negotiating position.

My feeling is that somewhere around £70 million could potentially get a deal done in January, although that’s my assessment rather than any inside information.

Then there’s Camara.

I’ve been consistent about this. He’s probably the player I’d personally lean towards.

I love his energy, his aggression and his ability to get around the pitch.

I’ve heard people suggest he’s too lightweight for the Premier League, and I couldn’t disagree more.

You don’t need to be six foot two to be an outstanding defensive midfielder.

N’Golo Kanté wasn’t a giant. Javier Mascherano wasn’t a giant.

What matters is how you compete, how you read the game and how effectively you use your physical attributes.

Camara has plenty of qualities that I believe would suit Liverpool.

Reports have suggested progress towards a potential deal, but we shouldn’t confuse encouraging speculation with a completed transfer.

There’s still work to do.

And ultimately, I trust Iraola to decide which player best fits his system.

Craig’s Column: Liverpool Must Sign Alex Scott Or Lamine Camara, And Keep Alexis Mac Allister

Liverpool Cannot Afford Another Midfield Transfer Mistake

My concern is that Liverpool will spend January talking about potential signings before eventually deciding the squad is strong enough.

We’ve heard that before.

And I don’t want to hear it again.

I agree with Jamie Carragher’s recent argument that Liverpool should be using January to prepare for next season.

I don’t realistically expect us to chase down Arsenal and win the Premier League this year.

But I absolutely expect Liverpool to be challenging for the title next season.

That means giving Iraola the players he needs as early as possible.

Bring somebody in during January and they’ve got several months to understand the system, develop relationships with their teammates and become comfortable with the demands of English football.

That’s a considerable advantage.

And with Iraola operating on a two-year contract, every transfer window matters.

We cannot afford to waste one.

I also want Liverpool to be smarter in the market.

I’m tired of watching players develop elsewhere before we suddenly decide they’re worth £80 million or £100 million.

We need to identify these footballers earlier.

Find the next Alex Scott before he becomes an £80 million player.

Find the next outstanding young centre-back before everybody in Europe is chasing him.

That’s what good recruitment should look like.

But we’re in the position we’re in now, and we need a midfielder.

So let’s address it.

Craig’s Column: Liverpool Must Sign Alex Scott Or Lamine Camara, And Keep Alexis Mac Allister

Alexis Mac Allister Must Stay At Liverpool

One thing I really cannot understand is the number of supporters suggesting we should sell Alexis Mac Allister.

Why?

Some people have told me he’s getting older, that his legs are going and that Liverpool should cash in while they can.

I understood those concerns last season.

I had some of them myself.

He wasn’t playing particularly well, and there were moments when I wondered whether we’d already seen his best football.

But look at him now.

For me, Mac Allister has probably been Liverpool’s best midfielder this season.

He’s moving better, he’s influencing games and he’s showing the intelligence and quality that made him such an important player in the first place.

He’s still only 27.

We’re talking about a World Cup winner and a Premier League winner who has enormous experience.

And Liverpool need that experience.

We’ve already lost so many influential personalities from the dressing room over recent years.

Jordan Henderson, James Milner, Andy Robertson, Mohamed Salah and Sadio Mané are among the players whose departures have changed the leadership dynamic.

We cannot keep allowing that experience to disappear without considering the consequences.

Mac Allister is exactly the sort of player I’d want around Trey Nyoni and the other younger members of the squad.

He could even become a serious candidate for the captaincy in the future.

And financially, selling him makes very little sense to me.

If we wait until next summer, when he’d have only a year remaining on his contract, what are we realistically getting?

Perhaps £40 million?

That’s my estimate, but it illustrates the problem.

We’d then have to spend considerably more replacing somebody who already understands Liverpool and is playing excellent football.

Reports from Fabrizio Romano and Ben Jacobs suggest conversations about a possible renewal are at an early stage, while Mac Allister’s father and agent has indicated talks are approaching.

I hope those discussions lead somewhere positive.

Give Mac Allister a new contract. Protect his value. Keep his experience in the dressing room.

And if things change in another year or two, Liverpool can reassess the situation.

That seems like common sense to me.

Craig’s Column: Liverpool Must Sign Alex Scott Or Lamine Camara, And Keep Alexis Mac Allister

Ryan Gravenberch Should Be Looking Over His Shoulder

Now, if we’re talking about potentially moving a midfielder on, I think we’re looking at the wrong player.

For me, Ryan Gravenberch should be the one under pressure.

And I don’t say that lightly.

Gravenberch was outstanding when Liverpool won the Premier League in 2024/25.

He deserves enormous credit for that campaign.

But we’re now well beyond that season, and I don’t think he’s consistently delivered the performances we need.

There’s also a tactical question that I keep coming back to.

What exactly is his best position in Iraola’s Liverpool team?

I don’t think he’s a natural number six in this system.

He’s certainly not a number ten.

He’s probably an eight, but Liverpool don’t really operate with a conventional number eight in the way we’re currently playing.

That’s a problem.

It’s not simply a question of form.

Dominik Szoboszlai has experienced difficult spells, but I can see several ways he can contribute.

He can operate deeper, play further forward, offer something from set pieces and provide tactical flexibility.

I believe he’ll come through his current struggles.

With Gravenberch, I’m less certain.

And when you consider the enormous wages he’s reportedly earning following his contract renewal, Liverpool have every right to expect more.

I’m not criticising the lad for securing a fantastic deal.

But a football club has to judge whether its investment is delivering the required performances.

Right now, I’m struggling to see it.

If Liverpool decide that a midfielder must leave to create space, I’d be far more comfortable discussing Gravenberch’s future than Mac Allister’s.

Of course, finding a buyer willing to meet his wages would be another challenge.

And I’m not suggesting we should sell him tomorrow.

Bring in the midfielder first.

Give Gravenberch the opportunity to compete.

Then make a decision based on what happens over the remainder of the season.

That’s how Liverpool should approach this.

I don’t want us weakening the squad before we’ve strengthened it.

I don’t want another summer dominated by avoidable problems.

And I certainly don’t want to lose Mac Allister while continuing to hope Gravenberch eventually finds a position that suits him.

So, whether it’s Alex Scott or Lamine Camara, my message to Liverpool is straightforward.

Listen to your manager.

Identify the player who makes this team better.

Get the deal done in January.

And make sure Alexis Mac Allister is still here to play alongside him.

Because if we’re serious about challenging for the Premier League next season, we need to start making those decisions now.

Much Love.

More: Craig’s Column: Daily Liverpool Opinion →

Live